Santa was good to me this year and dropped off the new La Sportiva Stratos Evo. I've been in the market for one of the new ultra light boots for a while, but finally chose the Stratos over the Scarpa Alien and the Dynafit Evo. Weight wise, in a size 27, it turns out the Stratos is probably the heaviest of the three, but negligibly so (40-50 grams). I think it may ski the best (without actually skiing the others) and ultimately, it was the stiffness of full carbon, the reputation of La Sportiva, and the sheer beauty finally swayed me.
Right away, the quality craftsmanship is noted on handling the boot. Handmade in Italy, the boot looks and feels like it could be worn with a suit (real suit that stiffs wear to work, not a skin suit). I thought I could just pull it out of the box and try it on but just as this video implies, some instruction is necessary. However, this is the new version of the Stratos, and actually isn't too cumbersome to figure out.
Starting with just the liner, I loosened the unique lacing system, slipped my foot in, and was happy straight away with the performance fit. Snugging up the laces and then wrapping them around the ankle a time or two and then keeping it all in place with a velcro tab also allows one to really dial in the fit. Once the liner is placed in the boot, a second velcro tab secures the forefoot in place and seems to internalize the 2nd "buckle" and make it perform consistently well as it doesn't pop open as with other boots. Finally, a well designed gaiter keeps snow out and streamlines the appearance.
|Liner firmly in place with velcro strap over forefoot|
|Close up of internal velcro "buckle"|
|To take the liner out, or place it in the shell, a portion of the cuff must be rotated 180 degrees, opening up the anterior aspect. However, the dyneema cord must first be unhooked from the buckle (see below)|
|Cuff rotated back into place|
|Dyneema cord that hooks to buckle. This must be undone to get in and out of the boot.|
|Dyneema cord hooked in place on buckle|
For a race boot, or any boot designed with speed in mind, the closure system needs to be swift and efficient. Scarpa and Pierre Gignoux use a vertical lever system that latches on the lower posterior aspect of the lower shell. When the lever is closed, it tightens the cord around the cuff and locks the whole mechanism into place. Genius. Dynafit has come up with an overlapping cuff that is locked into place with a side throw buckle. This horizontal lever has a pin that is inserted into a hole through the overlapping segments. Also genius. Both require a single action to transition between ski and walk mode. Sportiva has stepped into the game and created their own mechanism that appears to blend the other two. The Stratos have a horizontal throw that tightens the cord around the cuff and pulls a vertical lever into a notch in the back of the cuff. This locks the cuff in place as the lever spans from the lower shell to the above mentioned and pictured notch. It sounds complicated but in reality is smooth and really fast. My only concerns are the durability of the plastic appearing lever and the fact that the receiving notch is built into the carbon cuff without apparent reinforcement.
|Locked in ski mode|
As pictured above, the dyneema cord holds the whole shebang together. It can be adjusted to fit both skinny legs and cankles. I think mine are some where in between and will require a bit of fiddling since I still had a bit of room in the cuff to wiggle around.
One of the coolest aspects of the whole closure mechanism is how easy it is to release. When the buckle is opened, a tension bar pushes the vertical lever out of the notch and back into walk mode. This is something I fought with at times with my Dynafit boots and I was psyched to be able to transition with the flick of a finger.
|Unique tension bar that pushes the locking lever into walk mode once the buckle is released|
|Rearward articulation near maxed out|
|Forward articulation near max|
Durability in a full carbon boot is another big question mark. A friend who skis full carbon Pierre Gignoux 444s has broken them multiple times, often at inopportune times such as while racing (although another friend skied Mount Robson in them!). Carbon can crack and boots can break in a million different ways, but one area of wear that consistently appears is around the main rivets of the cuff. I'm sure all you owners of the TLT Performance know what I'm talking about if you've put in any serious mileage. All the new boots by Dynafit, Scarpa, and Sportiva appear to have at lease mitigated the problem by adding metal bushings to prevent the carbon on metal wear.
|Metal on metal|
And what kind of sole did Italian boot makers come up with? I'd have to say a surprisingly beefy Vibram sole that looks more at home on a traditional climbing boot. If any weight were to be shaved it seems it could have been done here but again, it looks like all attempts were made to produce a quality product that will last. The burly full sole also makes the thought of taking these "race boots" out for some real adventures.
|Full Vibram sole?|
So with the heavy sole, the overall weight (with some sweat from this mornings workout) checks in at 740-751 grams per boot in size 27.0. Advertised at 694 grams (534 for the shell and 165 for the liner) in size 26.0, I feel the weight is probably pretty accurate with with any marketing claims. The sneaky way the carbon boot manufacturers report weight can be misleading as Pierre Gignoux makes two boots, one the XP444 and the other the XP500 with the numbers being the weight of the shell. Needing to brush up on my Italian, I missed that the liner weighs as much as it does and thought the boot would check in a bit lighter. Chi se ne frega?
Oh, and did I mention the skis?
So I know the main question will be how do they ski? After one day with the cuff not properly adjusted to the girth of my leg, I'm really optimistic. It was slightly hard to discern the difference between the new boots and the new skis but at least the combination felt great. The boots are stiff and the skis feel like razors (read new and not abused) compared to my others. I might have to touch on the subject again once I have more days on the boots and have skied more than a couple groomers and soft chop.
But for now, I'm just psyched that Santa and his Italian little elves can make more than just rocking horses and other assorted crap. They really stepped up their game this year.
hey andy great morning thanks for the invite. let me know about the next one.ReplyDelete
You dog! Those look dope. You just joined the "must be nice" hall of fame.ReplyDelete
Glad you could come out Eric. See http://citizenseries.wasatchpowderkeg.com/ for updates on our informal racing series. And I'll be in touch about future training days.ReplyDelete
Thanks Layne. You should check out the link above too. Subscribe and you'll get emails of all the new posts.
Est ce qu'il y a une grande différence entre la stratos evo et la stratos normal ?
Thanks for the preview. Do you have any further comments to add after using them more?
Relating to the beautiful picture on the top of your blog, do you have recommendation for best boot for combined ski-rando / mixed climbing ?
I have been using Koflach plastic boot, which are OK for climbing, great for skinning up, but suck for descents. Now they are worn out and Koflach doesn't exist anymore. So any recommendations would be great.
I've used them dozens of times since this post and continue to be extremely impressed. They ski and walk amazingly and climb rock well too due to the short rockered sole (although they got a bit scratched up but without any serious damage). As for a light rando type boot that can be used for mixed climbing, the TLT Performance (used in the pic you mention) is probably the best option right now as far and cost and durability but the Alien and Evo are also really intriguing. Next year, La Sportiva will also have similar options.
Curious for a post-season assessment, and also a compare/contrast with Jason's Dynafit DyNA EVO boots?ReplyDelete
Also, what is the bsl for your size 27 boots?
After a season of use, my conclusion is that the boots and skis are amazing for racing but the boots were a little too fragile to use for much else. They ski like a dream and the carbon is really quite beautiful but as expected, not as durable as needed. I cracked them a couple times while racing through some rocks and had some trouble with the rear lever coming off the boot (although for intended use on snow they always did great). And, Sportiva was awesome at fixing anything that went wrong. Sorry, I'm not sure of the BSL, I seem to recall low 280s??? The skis were like any race ski...short, skinny, stiff, straight, and light. They get the job done. Compared to Jason's EVOs, I think the main difference is comfort and weight. The EVOs gave him no issues as far as fit goes but my boots gave me black toenails. I think this is from being just a little small but also from the way the liner is secured inside the shell. Unfortunately, I could never secure the liner as well as I wanted and there seemed to be a some play between the two. Also, we ran through the same rocks and skied the same stuff and his don't look like they even have a scratch.
And then there's the Alien 1.0....
Andy, thanks for the detailed follow-up. I've had my eye on the Dynafit DyNA EVO, since I've been so happy with the original DyNA (which I used for all of my skiing the first season I had it), and then the TLT5 for most of my non-rando race/train skiing in the two seasons since then. But that La Sportiva has been tempting me since it is just so beautifully crafted. Sounds though like all our granite rock scrambling out here in the spring to link up long ski tours would not be a good idea in them!ReplyDelete
Very good point of view!ReplyDelete
Not every blogger can write from different angles
I appreciate your way of blogging
Don’t hesitate to keep it up
Good luck. Cheers!
visit there to learn
How warm are these for multi day high altitude expedition style ski descent scenarios. Read 6000+ to 7000+ meter himalayan peaks over a period of 10-15 days.ReplyDelete